Bonuses 'a much broader category than I think a lot of human resources managers are aware of'
The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) is under scrutiny recently, as the federal broadcaster announced drastic job cuts last week, at the same time as it prepares to award annual bonuses to executives.
CBC CEO Catherine Tait said that executive bonuses, including her own which could be up to $120,000 on top of her six-figure salary, had not yet been discounted.
This comment has drawn fire, including from the House of Commons heritage committee which said it would be “inappropriate for the CBC to grant bonuses to executive members” while it simultaneously cuts 600 jobs and leaves another 200 vacancies unfilled.
While the CBC’s executive bonus scheme may be deemed “inappropriate” for a Crown Corporation by its governing body, and may result in bad PR, it isn’t illegal, said Micah Fysh, employment lawyer with Filion Wakely Thorup Angeletti in Toronto.
Bonus payments commonly paid incorrectly
“There are obviously public relations considerations whenever bonuses are being given to executives,” said Fysh. “Managers, executives and companies should consider the economic climate at the time when making decisions about bonuses.”
There are correct and incorrect ways to pay out bonuses, and many employers and HR professionals are doing it wrong – especially when it comes to properly assessing when bonuses are considered wages and when they’re not, he said.
“There are some types of bonuses, and arguably quite common bonuses, especially at lower levels, that would be considered wages under employment standards legislation, and that have carry-on effects to the calculation of various other entitlements under employment standards legislation.”
Bonuses in annual wages
A common misconception of HR professionals is failing to include bonuses in employee annual wages, he said. This can result in underpayment of overtime, public holiday premiums, vacation pay and termination pay, for example.
“If there is any relation to productivity, efficiency or hours in terms of the bonus plan, then the bonus would be still considered wages, at least under the Ontario Employment Standards Act, and would have to be included in the calculation of all of these other entitlements,” said Fysh.
“And that's a much broader category than I think a lot of human resources managers are aware of or really practice.”
Consequences of miscalculated bonuses
The main risk of miscalculated or missed statutory bonus payments is systemic underpayment, Fysh said, which could result in Ministry of Labour claims or even lawsuits.
For example, in a 2022 case, a class action lawsuit was filed against Medcan Health Management by a group of former employees who said they hadn’t been paid vacation and public holiday pay they were entitled to based on commission earnings, he said.
Upon investigation, Medcan discovered it had been underpaying upwards of 700 employees for over 15 years because of assuming commission was a discretionary bonus award and not actual wages. That case has still not been decided in court.
Ensure non-discretionary bonuses included in wage earnings
Since payouts of this type can be relatively small and tend not to be high profile, rules around bonuses can remain murky and mistakes are “not uncommon,” Fysh said.
This means employers should ensure that HR and payroll are on board with where bonuses are being counted, including making sure that discretionary awards such as end-of-year bonuses are “completely divorced” from any aspects of production, efficiency or hours.
“This can add up over a period of time, or over many employees, to have quite a significant impact in terms of amounts that could be owing to employees because of miscalculations,” said Fysh.
“So I think this is something that probably should be talked about more, so that more human resources individuals and professionals can spot these issues before they become issues with a capital ‘I’.”
